Which Variable Renewable Serves Pakistan’s Binding Hour? Metered Evidence After the Peak Moved to the Evening
Sheraz Hassan, Muhammad Sami Shahid
21/11/26
Pakistan’s contracted generating capacity is approximately 32% higher than its peak demand. We analyzed peak demand by reviewing hourly system operator data for fiscal years 2016-2025. In fiscal year 2025, the hour with the highest demand moved from 14:00 to 23:00. The data further indicated that 90% of the 50 binding hours (the highest demand hours of the year) occurred in the evening, up from 32% the year before. This shift is associated with the greater use of distributed solar power, which reduced the demand the operator sees during the day. Solar power does not generate at night; wind power’s capacity factor for the 50 binding hours was 0.504, and 0.239 for the year. Utility-scale solar had a capacity factor of 0.024 for those hours and 0.191 for the year.
In the May to September season of fiscal year 2025, wind’s hourly output was correlated with demand at +0.317, and utility solar’s at −0.347. A three-factor decomposition, which takes into account month and hour of the day, shows wind’s advantage comes mostly from the season, not hour of the day. In both years, the highest demand days were also windier than other days of the same month at the same hour. Monsoon wind output typically changes by 25-33% between years. Allowing generously for unrecorded wind curtailment does not change the comparison with solar. Because some rationing goes unrecorded, the recorded values are likely a lower bounding estimate.
Adding estimated distributed solar back to the demand value, with capacity held constant, moves the binding hours back to the afternoon and raises solar’s peak-coincidence ratio from 0.124 to 2.6-3.4, partly by construction. Solar’s ranking in Pakistan’s planning models may therefore reflect the demand curve before distributed solar spread.
