top of page

How Conversations Change Us: Supplying a Hermeneutic Mechanism for Dover’s Conversational Self

Weizhong Li
21/11/26

Daniela Dover argues that interpersonal inquiry is governed by an ethic of “taking one another seriously.” One of its conditions is abdication of interpretive sovereignty—giving up the privilege to have a last word on oneself. Committing to an ethics-first and phenomenological approach, Dover sets aside the question of how the changes to one’s self-understanding she attributes to this kind of conversation take place. I first argue that her account of the abdication condition rests on a false assumption of interpretive process: that a conscious vetting process stands between understanding an utterance and being changed by it, and can be suspended by will. Second, drawing on Gadamerian hermeneutics, I supply the hermeneutic mechanism by which the interlocutor’s utterance alters one’s self-understanding, and recover abdication as the foregrounding of prejudices and the turning of fore-structure toward oneself. Finally, I test this account by using it to explain what Dover asserts yet does not support: that changes to one’s self-understanding are unpredictable and untraceable in interpersonal inquiry.

bottom of page