Unpacking Post-Civil War Democratization: How Wartime Institutional Capacity Conditions the Effects of Conflict Termination on Post-War Democratization
Stephen R Tomeo
21/11/26
What variables meaningfully influence post-civil war democratization? Existing literature on post-civil war democratization has reached conflicting conclusions on whether negotiated settlements or decisive victories foster democracy, a disagreement that persists even under methodological corrections. To address this conflict, this paper presents a theoretical synthesis that identifies a critical missing variable: wartime institutional capacity. By synthesizing studies on conflict termination with theoretical accounts of wartime governance, the paper proposes a conditioning framework in which war termination type does not directly cause postwar regime outcomes, but instead presents a set of political tasks to the postwar state. This paper argues that whether a state can execute those tasks depends on the administrative machinery built during the conflict. The paper is primarily a literature review that compares four leading studies of conflict termination and a recent account of wartime governance. It then uses the gaps identified in that review to propose a theoretical framework centered on a missing variable: wartime institutional capacity. While purely theoretical, this framework offers a possible conceptual resolution to the field's conflicting findings and yields four testable directional hypotheses to guide future empirical research linking wartime administrative capacity to postwar democratic stability and decay.
