top of page

Art and Totalitarian Regimes: Why Did the Young Soviet Union Change Its Policy from Initially Supporting Avant-Garde Art to Suppressing It?

Alexandre Gimbrere
31/10/2026

Between 1917 and the end of the 1920s, Russian art faced a turning point, navigating from bold creative freedom to the first attempts at ideological regulation. This effervescent period, when suprematism and constructivism co-existed side by side, was the culmination of decades of artists' push for more freedom in a new society in which everything needed to be built from scratch. By the early 1930s, the state took control and imposed strict rules on art creation. For the clarity of this article, we will define a totalitarian regime as a political regime in which a single party or leader exercises absolute control over all aspects of public and private life, suppressing opposition and individual freedoms. In 1984, George Orwell identifies the characteristics of totalitarianism as follows: submission to an omnipresent glorified leader, denunciation praised as a civic virtue, social cohesion maintained by constant war against internal and external threats, creation of a new man, relentless surveillance, and propaganda. However, fear and coercion can only last so long. To protect its durability, such a regime has to win the hearts and minds of its people, and the young USSR turned to art to do just that.

Bolshevik Russia embodied a revolution, in the literal sense: a complete rupture with the past in their will to build a new man and a new society, by any means necessary. As expressed by Christine Lindey in “Art and the Bolshevik Revolution”, at the beginning, art was part of the revolutionary toolbox, first to contest the status quo and then to help create the new society. The Russian Avant-Garde was at the forefront of the push for the revolution, and artists and politicians were allied on their common goal to gain freedom from the past and create a new, better world. By the 1930s, however, the politicians took over and narrowly defined art and creation. We can ask ourselves what happened at that time and why there was a seemingly sudden change in policy. Was this change primarily driven by ideology, political consolidation, or something else? This is what we will explore in this article. This paper argues that the Soviet Union's shift from supporting avant-garde art to suppressing it was the result of the consolidation of stricter political control under Stalin: the artistic freedom of the early revolutionary period was tolerated because it served the immediate needs of the Revolution, but was replaced by state-controlled art once the regime sought to consolidate its power.

bottom of page