top of page
Search

How High Schoolers Can Spot Predatory Journals

Nov 9
8 min read

Updated: Nov 10

By the OJSS Editorial Team · Checked November 2026


In short: A predatory journal takes a publication fee without providing real editing or peer review, and wins authors with false claims. For high school students, the giveaways are unsolicited emails full of praise, invented impact factors, acceptance within days and fees that come with a promise of acceptance. If you already submitted, withdraw in writing and sign nothing.


Most students first hear the phrase "predatory journal" after an email has already landed in their inbox, praising a paper the sender has clearly never read. Parents and counselors usually hear about it later, when there is a payment receipt to explain. We're the editorial team at OJSS, and we charge fees ourselves, so we have every reason to be clear about where the line sits.


Our post How to Tell If a High School Journal Is Legit already gives an eight-point checklist for vetting any journal. This article explains what "predatory" means and where the term came from, how these operations find high school students, what the common scams look like up close, why paying a fee is not by itself a red flag, and what to do if you have already submitted or paid.


What does "predatory journal" actually mean?

A predatory journal collects fees while skipping the editing and peer review that make a journal a journal. The term describes behavior, not price.


The label comes from Jeffrey Beall, a librarian at the University of Colorado Denver, who began keeping a list of what he called "predatory" open access publishers in 2008. The list was influential and contested, and on 15 January 2017 Beall took his whole site offline. The list did not disappear, though: an anonymous researcher has kept an updated version going at beallslist.net, and librarians still point students to it. It does not explain why each title is listed, so treat a match as a reason to look closer rather than a final verdict.


In December 2019 a group of researchers and publishers agreed a consensus definition, published in Nature: predatory journals and publishers "prioritize self-interest at the expense of scholarship and are characterized by false or misleading information, deviation from best editorial and publication practices, a lack of transparency, and/or the use of aggressive and indiscriminate solicitation practices." The Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), in its 2019 discussion document, treats "predatory publishing" and "fake scholarly publishing" as the same thing.


A 2015 study in BMC Medicine by Cenyu Shen and Bo-Christer Björk estimated that about 8,000 active predatory journals published around 420,000 articles in 2014 alone.


A definition only helps if you can spot it in your inbox, so the next question is how these operations reach students.


How do predatory journals find high school students?

Mostly by email. Predatory publishers send unsolicited "call for papers" messages in bulk, and a student who has posted a paper, presented at a fair or appeared on a conference program is an easy address to find.


The emails share a voice: heavy praise for "your outstanding research," a paper title scraped from somewhere public, an invitation to a "special issue" or an editorial board, and a short deadline. Some address a teenager as "Dr." Real editors rarely write to a high school student out of the blue asking for a manuscript. This is the "aggressive and indiscriminate solicitation" in the Nature definition.


A typical pitch reads something like this composite, built from the patterns above rather than copied from one real email: "Dear Dr. Patel, we read your outstanding research on microplastics in local water with great interest and invite you to contribute to our Special Issue. Papers received within 7 days qualify for fast-track publication. Kindly reply to this email with your manuscript." Notice the title lifted from a public page, the invented deadline, and a submission process that is just a reply to an email.


What do predatory journal scams look like up close?

The same handful of tactics come up again and again. Each sounds reassuring until you check it.


Fake impact factors and "indexing" claims

The Journal Impact Factor is a specific number calculated each year by Clarivate and published in its Journal Citation Reports, and only journals covered in its Web of Science Core Collection get one. Predatory sites show look-alike metrics built from words like "impact," "factor" or "global." Indexing claims work the same way: "indexed in Google Scholar" says little, since Google Scholar picks up almost anything formatted like a paper. Most new student journals, OJSS included, have no Clarivate impact factor.


Hijacked and clone websites

Some scammers copy a real journal's name, ISSN and design onto a new domain and collect fees from authors who think they are submitting to the original. The Retraction Watch Hijacked Journal Checker, compiled by researcher Anna Abalkina, passed 400 entries in December 2025. If the web address came from an email, find the journal independently before sending anything.


Acceptance in days

Peer review takes time because someone has to read the paper closely and write comments. An acceptance within a few days, with no reviewer comments, means nobody reviewed it. For comparison, our standard review track takes 11 to 16 weeks in total, and every paper we accept goes through at least one round of revision first.


Fees at submission with acceptance promised

Watch for payment demanded up front alongside a promise of publication. A legitimate journal may charge at submission for a service, but it cannot promise the outcome of a review that has not happened.


Fake editorial boards

Predatory journals list impressive names on their boards, sometimes without consent. In 2019 a US federal court, in a case brought by the Federal Trade Commission against the publisher OMICS Group, found that many people presented as its editors had never agreed to the role, and entered a $50.1 million judgment.


Conferences that are really fee mills

The same case covered OMICS conferences that advertised researchers as speakers without their agreement. Predatory conferences accept almost any abstract, take a registration fee and deliver little, sometimes no event at all. The Think. Check. Attend. checklist asks who organizes the event, where it is held, who reviews submissions and where proceedings are published.


The table below pairs the claims students most often see with what each one usually turns out to mean.


What the pitch says

What it often means

How to check

"Impact factor 4.8" or a "Global" or "Universal" impact factor

A made-up metric

Search the journal in Clarivate's Journal Citation Reports (your school or local library may have access)

"Indexed in Google Scholar" or a list of database logos

Little or no real indexing

Search the database itself for the journal title

"Accepted" within days of submission

No peer review took place

Ask to see the reviewer comments

Fee due now, publication promised

The fee is the product

Read what the fee buys and whether rejection is possible

Well-known professors on the board

Names used without consent

Check those people's own university pages for the affiliation

Website address came from an email

Possibly a hijacked clone

Search the Retraction Watch Hijacked Journal Checker


Several of these tactics involve money, which leads to the question parents ask us most: does charging a fee make a journal predatory?


Is a pay-to-publish journal always a scam?

No. Many reputable open access journals charge an article processing charge, because the journal is free to read and someone has to pay for editing, hosting and DOIs. A fee becomes a scam when it is hidden until late, when it is presented as buying acceptance, or when nothing is delivered for it.


For comparison, OJSS charges a $230 APC only after acceptance, which follows peer review and at least one revise-and-resubmit. Our optional $250 Fast-Track is paid at submission and buys speed, not acceptance: it guarantees an initial decision by day 14, and that decision can be a rejection. Details are on our APC page, and Do High Schoolers Pay to Publish Research? compares fees across student journals. OJSS is independent and is not affiliated with the University of Oxford.


Want to see what a reviewed student journal actually publishes? Browse every OJSS issue, read a few papers in your field, and judge the editing for yourself. Read Our Issues.


The signs help before you submit. It is harder when the paper is already out of your hands.


What should you do if you already submitted or paid?

Act quickly and in writing. Until a paper is published you can usually still pull it back; we would take these steps in this order.


  1. Stop and sign nothing. Do not sign a copyright transfer or publishing agreement. If you hand over copyright, a legitimate journal may later be unable to publish your paper.

  2. Withdraw in writing. Email the journal saying you withdraw the manuscript, giving its title and any submission number, and asking for written confirmation. In the OMICS case, the FTC alleged that authors who asked to withdraw were often refused, which left their work stuck.

  3. Dispute the charge if you paid. Contact your card issuer or bank, explain what was promised, and include your emails. The FTC publishes a sample letter for disputing card charges.

  4. Keep every record. Save the solicitation email, the website as it looked, invoices and replies.

  5. Don't list it. Leave it off applications and résumés as a publication. You can still describe the research itself as a project.

  6. Tell your counselor or mentor. They can help with the withdrawal email.


One practical point if you intend to send the paper to us next: OJSS does not accept concurrent submissions, so get the withdrawal confirmed before you submit.


Picture a hypothetical student who pays a $150 fee after a two-day "acceptance" and only then notices the journal names no editors. She emails a withdrawal the same day, keeps the reply, disputes the charge with her bank using the saved emails, and once the withdrawal is confirmed sends the paper to a journal with real review. The research is not wasted. Only the first venue was.


Where should you send your paper instead?

Pick journals that are open about their review process and run the eight checks in How to Tell If a High School Journal Is Legit on each. The Think. Check. Submit. checklist, backed by COPE, DOAJ and other publishing bodies, is a good second opinion. 9 Journals That Publish High School Research lists venues by type, and if OJSS fits, our submission guidelines explain exactly what we ask for.


Frequently asked questions

Are predatory journals illegal?

Running a low-quality journal is not illegal in itself, but deceiving authors can be. The FTC's case against OMICS Group, decided in 2019, ended in a $50.1 million judgment over false claims about peer review, editors and indexing, and hidden fees.


Is Beall's List still updated?

Yes, though not by Beall himself. He took his original site down in January 2017, but an anonymous researcher maintains an updated version at beallslist.net (last updated December 2024 when we checked). It is still a useful first check. Because it gives no reasons for each listing, follow it up with the checks in this article.


Will a predatory publication hurt a college application?

We can't speak for admissions offices and have no data on this. A paper in a journal with no real review shows a reader very little, and an obvious predatory venue invites awkward questions.


Is OJSS affiliated with the University of Oxford?

No. OJSS is an independent journal registered in Wilmington, Delaware. Most of our editorial board are University of Oxford doctoral candidates and postdocs, and you can see who they are on our editorial board page.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page