top of page
Search

How to Revise and Resubmit a High School Research Paper

Nov 2
4 min read

Updated: Nov 11

By the OJSS Editorial Team · Checked November 2026


In short: "Revise and resubmit" means the journal wants to publish your paper, provided you fix what the reviewer raised. For high school authors it's the normal route to publication, not a polite rejection. Read the comments twice, make the changes, and send back the revised paper with a short letter explaining what you changed for each point.

Most high school students who get "revise and resubmit" on their first paper read it as a no. It isn't. At OJSS, every paper we've ever accepted went through at least one round of it. There is no path to publication here that skips revisions, and at most serious journals that's true for professional researchers too.


As the editors who send these decisions at OJSS, we'll walk you through what the decision means, how long you have, how to work through the comments day by day, how to write the response letter, and what happens after you resubmit.


What the decision means for your paper

Journals use slightly different labels, but they usually sort into three outcomes:


Decision

What it means

What to do

Reject

The paper won't be published here

Read the comments anyway; they're free feedback for the next journal

Revise and resubmit (conditional acceptance)

The paper can be published if the concerns are addressed

Revise within the deadline

Accept

Ready for typesetting

At OJSS this only comes after resubmission


A revise and resubmit doesn't guarantee acceptance. If the revisions don't address the main concerns, the paper can still be declined, or sent back for another round. But the editors have decided the core of your work is worth publishing. That's the hard part done. What's left is doing the work before the clock runs out.


Your deadline

At OJSS you have 14 days to resubmit. That's enough time for most revisions if you start immediately, and not enough if you wait a week to open the email. If you need longer because of AP exams, finals, a college application deadline or a substantial reanalysis, email the editor before the deadline. Extensions are considered case by case. Silence is the one thing that reliably hurts you. Here is how we'd use those 14 days.


How to work through the comments

Day 1: read, don't write. Read every comment twice. Some will sting. Close the document and come back the next day.


Day 2: make a table. Copy each reviewer comment into a row. Next to it, write what you'll do: change it, partly change it, or explain why not. This table becomes your response letter later.


Days 3 to 10: do the work. Start with the big comments (your question, your method, a gap in your evidence) before the small ones (wording, formatting, citations). Big changes often make small comments irrelevant.


Days 11 to 13: write the response letter and reread the whole paper. Revisions in one section often create contradictions in another, especially between your abstract and your conclusion.


Day 14: submit.


A common major comment is that the research question is broader than the evidence can support. Reviewers may ask you to narrow your claims, strengthen your analysis, or explain how your findings support your conclusions. Whatever you change, the response letter is where you show the reviewer you did it.


How to write the response letter

Keep it short, specific and polite. For each comment:


  1. Quote or summarize the comment.

  2. Say what you changed.

  3. Say where (section or page) the reviewer can find it.


A good response:


Reviewer comment 3: The sample of 42 students may not support conclusions about all high school students. Response: Agreed. We have narrowed the conclusion to students at the surveyed school and added a limitations paragraph (Discussion, final section).


A weak response:


We have addressed all of the reviewer's comments.


Can you disagree with a reviewer?

Yes, if you have a reason. Reviewers are sometimes wrong, or ask for something your data can't do. Say so respectfully and explain why: "We considered adding X, but our dataset doesn't include Y, so we've noted this as a limitation instead." Editors respect a reasoned disagreement far more than a change made only to please someone.


What doesn't work is ignoring a comment. If you don't respond to a point, the reviewer will assume you missed it. That is one of the mistakes we see most often. Here are the others.


Mistakes we see most often

  • Changing the paper without explaining the changes, so the reviewer has to hunt for them.

  • Fixing the wording of a comment but not the substance.

  • Adding new claims that the reviewer then has to evaluate from scratch.

  • Leaving the abstract unchanged after the conclusions changed.

  • Missing the deadline without writing to the editor.


What happens after you resubmit

The reviewer and the editor check whether the concerns were addressed. At OJSS, resubmission review takes 1 to 2 weeks on Standard Review and about a week on Fast-Track. The result is a final acceptance, another round of revisions, or, rarely, a rejection. Accepted papers move to the $230 Article Processing Charge, typesetting and publication.


Haven't submitted yet? Every OJSS author gets detailed reviewer feedback, even if the answer is no. Start with our Submission Guidelines, and see Review Timelines for how long each stage takes.

Frequently asked questions

Is revise and resubmit good or bad? Good. It means the journal intends to publish your paper once the reviewer's concerns are fixed.


How many rounds of revisions are normal? One or two. A third round usually means the main concern hasn't been addressed.


Should my teacher or mentor write the response letter? They can advise you, but the letter and the revisions should be yours. Reviewers can tell, and if a college asks about the paper later, you'll need to explain every change yourself.


Do other high school journals use revise and resubmit? Yes. NHSJS, for example, can return a paper with minor or major revisions, and the revised paper goes through another review of about 4 weeks on its standard track. At OJSS, every accepted paper goes through at least one round.


Can I withdraw and submit somewhere else instead? Yes, you can withdraw at any point. You'd start again at the new journal, usually with a longer wait.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page